A Cuckoo’s Nest that no one can fly over – Chinese petitioner locked up again 8 days after escape

May 3, 2011Jing Gao7 Comments, , , , , , , , ,

From Southern Metropolis Daily and Tianya

Xu Wu, once an employee of a steel company in Wuhan, capital city of central Hubei province, had been petitioning in Beijing trying and failing to get justice on a financial dispute between himself and his company was forcibly admitted to a mental hospital and mistreated for four years. Eight days after he sprung up from the lunatic asylum, Xu was seized by the police a thousand kilometers away from home and thrown back into the asylum without any logical explanation. (Read how a Chinese whistleblower had been wronged and detained in mental home for 14 years)

Xu Wu, 43 year old, is a Wuhan native. He worked as a firefighter for Wuhan Iron and Steel Company (WISCO) before 2004. Believing that he was a victim of unequal pay and constant arrears of wages, he brought WISCO to court. The company wanted to settle with him out of court and pay him 30,000 yuan ($3,600) as compensation, only to be refused by him, because he wanted to win the lawsuit and his dignity.


Xu Wu in front of a bullet train after his escape from the mental home

After his claims were dismissed by the court, he appealed to Wuhan and Beijing’s government organs. On a day in December, 2006, the moment he stepped out of Peking University after consulting a legal aid center, he was seized by police coming all the way from Wuhan and escorted back to the local public security office. The police convinced him that as long as he pleaded mental illness, he could be released. However, his compliance landed him in the mental hospital affiliated to WISCO. He managed to break free from the asylum on March 29 2007 by cutting the chain lock with a saw he found. He ran to as far as Beijing, but was sent back under escort soon.

Xu Wu claimed that he suffered substantial abuses in there, including electric shocks while being hung up. Remarkably he had never given up thought of extricating himself and had been doing exercises every day for a better shot at the escape. At midnight on April 19, he bent iron bars installed on a window in a vacant ward and wriggled out from between, a method he learned from a Jet Li movie he watched in the hospital.

Xu Wu borrowed money from a friend and got on a train to Guangzhou a thousand kilometers away from Wuhan, hoping to get out of harm’s way and be helped by the city which is renowned for having the country’s best respected and civic-minded news organizations. On April 22, he went through a professional mental health check up in a hospital in Guangzhou, and was diagnosed by Dr. Lin only to be ‘low self-esteem, suffering from mild depression.’ He approached TVS, a Guangzhou-based broadcaster, and was interviewed on April 27.

What happened next flabbergasts reasonable minds: after the interview, Xu got into a cab at the side entrance of the TV station – for fear that the front entrance would be ambushed by Xu’s captor – and was leaving for a local newspaper office. Right in front of a TV reporter’s eyes, their taxi cab was waylaid by a dozen men who claimed to be the police. They dragged Xu’s father out of the cab and then got into the cab to take Xu away. It is now known that Xu Wu is again mandatory hospitalized in the WISCO No. 2 hospital again. The whole kidnapping process has been captured by the surveillance camera at the intersection and many videos have since been posted on the internet.

xu wu01xuwu02xuwu03xuwu04

A bunch of “policemen” without wearing uniform, displaying identification or paperwork, ambushed the taxi cab that Xu Wu took.

This incident has sent a big shockwave to the media circle in Guangzhou. The next day Southern Metropolis Daily sent its reporter Xu Jiguang (纪许光) to that hospital in Wuhan. But he got beaten up by security guards in the hospital, and was followed around by people he doesn’t know.

From the days Xu Wu fled and got captured until today, WISCO and the public security office that hunted down Xu Wu rejected all interview requests from the media. Xu Wu’s parents were also denied visits to their son still in the custody of the mental hospital.


Xu’s father and mother, both in their 70s, were denied visits to their son thrown back to the mental home. Desperate to see him, they stood outside the fence and cried to the third floor where Xu is supposedly detained, “My son Wu, come out and take a look at your mom.”

Zhang Anping, director of Retirement Office at a branch plant of WISCO, talked to reporters of Southern Metropolis Daily. He said even though he is also an employee of WISCO, being in different plant areas, he knew little about the inside story of Xu Wu’s case. However, he knew that Xu’s father went to WISCO multiple times to bring him out of the hospital home and always failed.

Zhang Anping thinks that the only condition for the release of Xu Wu is that he behaves and stops his petitioning effort. “The key issue is, even his father cannot guarantee that Xu Wu can give up on petitioning after he gets out. Nowadays stability trumps everything. As far as I know, the police have quite a lot of complaints about it. It is not good if he creates some mess again after he is let out,” he said.

Chen Zhonghua, a staff member at the mental hospital, said, “We complained that this person does not belong here long ago. But people higher above just won’t let him out. Every time he ran away, we are held accountable.”

xu wu02

Xu Wu’s parents at the gate of a mental hospital holding Xu’s I.D. photo.

In China, fabricating a mental health report is much easier than getting through the complex judiciary mill. Once one is identified as a person of unsound mind, his words are neither trusted nor legally effective. If mental hospitals are out of sight of public and judicial scrutiny, it can become a black jail where citizens are persecuted without being noticed.

This case is especially terrifying in the sense that the company in cahoots with the mental hospital are so powerful that the heavy hand of the local police came down on a patient at worst a thousand kilometers away from their due jurisdiction and has not relented a bit even after word about the incident spread nationwide quickly via the media and the web.

A net user commented, “If the matter is let to slide, it will leave people in constant nightmare.”

Related articles:

7 comments to “A Cuckoo’s Nest that no one can fly over – Chinese petitioner locked up again 8 days after escape”

  1. G in LA | May 3, 2011 | Permalink Reply

    Reminiscent of the recent movie "Changeling", lest people think such things could never happen in a Western country. Not to excuse China…whatever group of people is responsible for this, from those giving orders down to those carrying them out, deserve to have their testicles injected with the grubs of parasitic insects.

  2. [...] officers abducted Xu while still inside the TV station campus and escorted him back to Wuhan. Read a translation of a news piece telling Xu's story at the Ministry of Tofu [...]

  3. bobbbbbbbb | May 5, 2011 | Permalink Reply

    The following information is supplementary. Would this information change your opinion about the case of Xu Wu? It might. If Xu Wu wasn’t mentally incompetent, he would be facing some very serious criminal charges that can lead to a very long jail sentence. Anyway, why wasn’t this background not mentioned in Internet discussions or mainstream media reports? Maybe they didn’t know, or they knew but decided that it was inconvenient for their story. In any case, here it is.

    (Xinhua) 43-year-old Wuhan Steel Factory worker Xu Wu had been fined repeatedly for absenteeism and other disciplinary violations. As a result, Xu Wu had plenty of conflicts with his employer.

    On December 2, 2006, Xu Wu said openly that he “will bomb Tiananmen Square in Beijing with dynamite.” On December 16, Xu Wu was arrested by the Beijing police at Tiananmen Square. At the time, the police found on his person the recipe for building a bomb from dynamite, an electrician’s production knife as well as the raw materials required to cause an explosion. Xu Wu was transferred back to the Wuhan police. Based upon the , the Wuhan police held Xu Wu under criminal detention for a bombing attempt. On December 27, the father Xu Guibin petitioned the police to have Xu Wu undergo a psychiatric examination. On December 29, the Wuhan Psychiatric Hospital determined that Xu Wu suffered from paranoid schizophrenia and recommended long-term supervised treatment. Based upon Article 18 of the , the police relieved Xu Wu of the criminal liability (on the ground that he had been mentally incompetent). On December 31, 2006, the Wuhan Steel Number Two Hospital Department of Psychiatric took Xu Wu in for treatment. During his treatment, the Wuhan Steel Factory kept paying for the salary and other work benefits of Xu Wu.

    In May 2007, Xu Wu escaped from the psychiatric hospital and went to cause trouble again at Tiananmen Square in Beijing. During the process, Xu Wu injured a Beijing police officer. He was taken back to Wuhan to continue the supervised treatment. On November 2008, the Wuhan City Psychiatric Hospital evaluated Xu Wu again and determined that he was still suffering from paranoid schizophrenia. The recommendation was to continue the supervised treatment.

    On April 19, 2011, Xu Wu escaped from the psychiatric hospital once again. The Wuhan Steel Factory and the Wuhan Steel Factory Number Two Hospital reported his escape to the police on the same day. Acting in accordance with the law (Article 14 of the and Article 29 Clause 2 of the , the Wuhan police worked with the Guangzhou police to intercept Xu Wu on the road outside the Tongjing restaurant, Yuexiu district, Guangzhou city to fetch Xu Wu back to Wuhan to continue his treatment at the psychiatric hospital.

  4. [...] officers abducted Xu while still inside the station campus and escorted him back to Wuhan. Read a translation of a news piece telling Xu’s story at the Ministry of Tofu [...]

  5. [...] σταθμού και τον οδήγησαν πάλι πίσω στο Wuhan. Διαβάστε μια μετάφραση ενός ειδησεογραφικού αποσπάσματος που διηγείται την ιστορία του Xu στο blog Ministry of [...]

  6. [...] for at protestere mod ulovlig ekspropriation og køres derefter brutalt ned af politiet, og denne mand indlægges på sindssygehospital for at kræve retfærdig [...]

  7. Jesse Dziedzic | October 20, 2011 | Permalink Reply

    An all ’round good article!!

Leave a Reply